Eco-compensation effects of the wetland recovery in Dongting Lake area

  • 1. Department of Resources and Environmental Sciences, Changsha University of Science and Technology, Changsha 410114, China;;
    2. Key Laboratory for Agro-ecological Processes in Subtropical Region, Institute of Subtropical Agriculture, CAS, Changsha 410125, China
Xiong Ying (1977?), Ph.D and Associate Professor, specialized in the study of regional ecology and land use/land cover change. E-mail: xiong2001ying@126.com

Received date: 2009-05-11

  Revised date: 2009-09-01

  Online published: 2010-06-15


Eco-compensation is an environmental economic instrument for internalization of external cost. Returning farmland to lake is one of the important parts of restoring wetland ecosystem function in the Yangtze River Valley of China. Whether the project of lake recovery can be successful depends on the compensation to the farmers who have lost their original benefits and contributed to the wetland ecosystem recovery by returning farmland to lake. Aiming at the wetland recovery of the Dongting Lake, the practical implementation of programs of the lake recovery and flood control in this area has been challenged by the heavy task of population resettlement, so it is an ideal area for case studies to reach the academic objectives proposed as the above. Based on field survey and experimentation, this research evaluated the benefit losses of the resettled farmers and the increased values of ecosystem service functions caused by wetland recovery, and furthermore, the value of eco-compensation for relocated farmers was calculated by considering the combination of the farmers’ compensation appeal. The value of eco-compensation for relocated farmers in the Dongting Lake area was 6084.5 yuan per household by synthetic analysis of the effects on wetland ecosystem restoration. Moreover, this article took Dongting Lake area as a case to study and explore the basic issues of the eco-compensation by returning farmland to lake, that was who should pay, who should be paid, how much the payment was and what the payment means was, which sought the mechanisms of wetland restoration eco-compensation and prompted the people’s enthusiasms for ecological restoration.

Cite this article

XIONG Ying, WANG Kelin . Eco-compensation effects of the wetland recovery in Dongting Lake area[J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2010 , 20(3) : 389 -405 . DOI: 10.1007/s11442-010-0389-1


[1] Allen O A, Feddema J J, 1996. Wetland loss and substitution by the Section 404 Permit Program in Southern California. Environmental Management, 20(2): 263–274.

[2] Aschwanden J, Birrer S, Jenni L, 2005. Are ecological compensation areas attractive hunting sites for common kestrels (Falco tinnunculus) and long-eared owls (Asio otus)? J. Ornithol., 146: 279–286.

[3] Atinson R B, Perry J E, Smith E, Cairns J J, 1993. Use of created wetland delineation and weighted averages as a component of assessment. Wetlands, 13(3): 185–193.

[4] Becker N, 1999. A comparative analysis of water price support versus drought compensation scheme. Agricultural Economics, 21(1): 81–92.

[5] Blaine T W, Lichtkoppler F R, Jones K R et al., 2005.An assessment of household willingness to pay for curbside recycling: A comparison of payment card and referendum approaches. Journal of Environmental Management, 76: 15–22.

[6] Bu Y X, Lu Q G, Tan J G, 2001. The condition and evaluation of water population in Dongting Lake. Yangtze River, 32(2): 40–43. (in Chinese)

[7] Carsten D, 2000. Regulations, methods and experiences of land reclamation in German opencast mines. Addressed to Mine Land Reclamation and Ecological Restoration for 21st Century. Beijing International Symposium on Land Reclamation, 11–21.

[8] Coles B J, 1995. Archaeology and wetland restoration. In: Wheeler B D, Shaw S C, Fojt W J et al. Restoration of Temperate Wetlands. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 19–32.

[9] Costanza R, d′Arge R, de Groot R et al., 1998. The value of the world′s ecosystem services and natural capital. Ecological Economics, 25(1): 3–15.

[10] Cui B S, Liu X T, 1999. Review of wetland restoration studies. Advance in Earth Sciences, 14(4): 358–364. (in Chinese)

[11] Cuperus R, Bakermans M M, De H H et al., 2001. Ecological compensation in Dutch highway planning. Environmental Management, 27(1): 75–89.

[12] Cuperus R, Canters K J et al., 1999. Guidelines for ecological compensation associated with highways. Biological Conservation, 90: 41–51.

[13] Deng R, 2005. Brief talk on ecological compensation system when protecting rain forests in Xishuangbanna. Yunnan Environmental Sciences, 24: 65–67. (in Chinese)

[14] Ding C X, 2002. Exploration of ecology environmental compensation institution. Environmental Monitoring in China, 18(5): 8–9. (in Chinese)

[15] Du S K, 2001.Environment Economics: Theory Discussion and Demonstration Research. Beijing: China Cyclopaedia Press, 79–120. (in Chinese)

[16] Hashisaki S, 1996. Functional wetland restoration: An ecosystem approach. Science, 70(4): 348–351.

[17] Henry C P, Amoros C, 1995. Restoration ecology of riverine wetland (I): A scientific case. Environmental Management, 19(6): 891–902.

[18] Henry S F, 2000. The evolution of derelict land reclamation within the United Kingdom: A local government perspective. Addressed to Mine Land Reclamation and Ecological Restoration for 21 Century. Beijing International Symposium on Land Reclamation, 7–10.

[19] Herzog F, Dreier S, Hofer D, Marfurt C, 2005. Effect of ecological compensation areas on floristic and breeding bird diversity in Swiss agricultural landscapes. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 108: 189–204.

[20] Hong S Q, Ma P J, Guo H G, 2001.Discussion on ecological compensation system. Environmental Science & Technology, (5): 40–45. (in Chinese)

[21] Karin J, Martin D, Frank W, 2002. An ecological economic modeling procedure to design compensation payments for the efficient spatiotemporal allocation of species protection measures. Ecological Economics, 41(1): 37–49.

[22] Keller M, Kollmann J, 1999. Effects of seed provenance on germination of herbs for agricultural compensation sites. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 72: 87–99.

[23] Kleijn D, Berendse F, Smit R et al., 2004. Ecological effectiveness of agri-environment schemes in different agricultural landscapes in The Netherlands. Biological Conservation, 18: 775–786.

[24] Larson J S, 1994. Rapid assessment of wetlands: History and application to management. In: Mitsch (ed.). Global Wetlands: Old World and New. Elsevier, 623–636.

[25] Li H, Pang X M, Fu H, 2002. Social economic effect of lake recovery and population relocation in Dongting Lake area. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 11(3): 105–110. (in Chinese)

[26] Li J B, Zhu X, Cai B H, 2001. Eco-agricultural patterns for disaster prevention in wetland restoration area of Dongting Lake. Journal of Natural Disasters, 10(4): 108–112. (in Chinese)

[27] Liu D L, 2003. The current study on forest ecological benefits compensation. Jilin Forestry Science and Technology, 32(1): 22–25. (in Chinese)

[28] Liu G H, Zhang H Y, Wan J et al., 2006. Drainage area’s ecological compensation mechanism discussion on the north of Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei Province. China Population, Resources and Environment, 16(4): 120–124. (in Chinese)

[29] Lu H W, Zeng G M, Xie G X et al., 2003. The regional ecological risk assessment of the Dongting Lake watershed. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 23(12): 2520-2529. (in Chinese)

[30] Luis G, 2002. Outline for Presentation: The Use of Market Instruments for Environmental Services in Costa Rica. Workshop on Payment Schemes for Environmental Service, Apr.: 22–23.

[31] Mao X Q, Zhong Y, Zhang S, 2002. Conception, theory and mechanism of eco-compensation. China Population, Resources and Environment, 12(4): 38–41. (in Chinese)

[32] Mitsch K J, Wu X Y, Robert W et al., 1998. Creating and restoring wetland. Biological Science, 48(12): 1019–1030.

[33] Mitsch W J, Wilson R F, 1996. Improving the success of wetland creation and restoration with know-how, time, and self-design. Eco. Appl., 6(1): 77–83.

[34] Ni X M, Chen L, Zhou Y J et al., 1995. Study on the restoration and control technique of plants in Dong Lake. In: Chen Y Y. Study of Wetland in China. Changchun: Jilin Science and Technology Press, 211–221. (in Chinese)

[35] Qin L J, Qiu H, 2005. Study on water resources compensation in Songliao River Basin. Journal of Natural Resources, 20(1): 14–20. (in Chinese)

[36] Sierra R, Russmana E, 2006. On the efficiency of environmental service payments: A forest conservation assessment in the Osa Peninsula, Costa Rica. Ecological Economics, 59(1): 131–141.

[37] Skarback E, 2007. Urban forests as compensation measures for infrastructure development. Urban Forestry & XIONG Ying et al.: Eco-compensation effects of the wetland recovery in Dongting lake area 405 Urban Greening, 6(4): 279–285.

[38] Sun X Z, Xie G D, Zhang Q Z et al., 2006. Ecological compensation practice and policy orientation in China. Resources Science, 28(4): 25–30.

[39] Torok L S, Lockwood S, Fanz D, 1996. Review and comparison of wetland impacts and mitigation requirements between New Jersey, USA, Fresh Water Wetlands Protection Act and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. Environmental Management, 20(5): 741–752.

[40] Wang J L, Ma W M, 2002. Study of valley ecology compensation question. Journal of Soil Water Conservation, 16(6): 82–83. (in Chinese)

[41] Wang L M, Yang Y F, Wu Q F, 2001. Environment emigration stress of slope farmland in the three gorges area. Acta Geographica Sinica, 56(6): 649–656. (in Chinese)

[42] Wilson R F, Mitsch W J, 1996. Functional assessment of five wetlands constructed to mitigate wetland loss in Ohio, USA. Wetlands, 16(4): 436–451.

[43] Wu S R, Ma T L ,Zhao W, 2001.The development of forest eco-benefit compensation policy and economic analysis. Forest Economics, (4): 20–23. (in Chinese)

[44] Wu X Q, Tuo Z Y, Yang C M et al., 2003. A probe into ecological compensation mechanism in conservation areas of China. Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 19(2): 18–21. (in Chinese)

[45] Xin K, Xiao D N, 2002. Wetland ecosystem service valuation: A case researches on Panjin area. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 22(8): 1345–1349. (in Chinese)

[46] Xiong Y, Wang K L, Li H, 2002. Patterns of population relocation in the Dongting Lake area. Tropical Geography, 22(4): 320–324. (in Chinese)

[47] Xu Z M, Zhang Z Q, Cheng G D et al., 2002. Measuring the total economic value of restoring Ejina Banner’s ecosystem services. Acta Geographica Sinica, 57(1): 107–116. (in Chinese)

[48] Ye W H, Wei B, Tong C, 1998, Measurement and application of urban ecological compensation. China Environmental Science, 18(4): 298–301. (in Chinese)

[49] Yu X B, Han Y J, Lei G C, 1999. The bulletin of bank-yard economic and eco-environment questionnaire investigate in the middle of Yangtze River. In: Bulletin of Yangtze River Project (WWF), 36–40. (in Chinese)

[50] Zedler J B, Williams G D, Desmond J S, 1997. Wetland mitigation: Can fishes distinguish between natural and constructed wetland? Fisheries, 22(3): 26–28.

[51] Zhang C L, Ruan B Q, 2003. The economy analysis on water resources restoration and compensation. Water Conservancy Science and Technology and Economy, 9(1): 3–5. (in Chinese)

[52] Zhang G G, 2002. Effect of re-submerging particular polders on the ecological environment of Dongting Lake. Yangtze River, 33(5): 39–41. (in Chinese)

[53] Zhao J K, Zhu M M, 1991. Land management and its reclamation of America open-pit mine. China Land Science, (1): 31–33. (in Chinese)

[54] Zhen L, Min Q W, Li W H et al., 2006. Socio-economic impact and eco-compensation mechanism in natural reserves of Hainan Province. Resources Science, 28(6): 10–19. (in Chinese)

[55] Zhong Y, Zhang S, Mao X Q, 2002. Study on eco-compensation of returning land to lake. China Population, Resources and Environment, 12(4): 46–50. (in Chinese)

[56] Zhuang D C, Ou W X, Ding D S, 2003. Evaluation of the lake recovery area eco-economy benefit in Dongting wetland. Journal of Natural Resources, 18(5): 536–543. (in Chinese)