The driving effects of urbanization on economic growth and water use change in China: A provincial-level analysis in 1997-2011

doi:10.1007/s11442-015-1185-8

Abstract

Abstract:

As one of the key issues in China’s sustainable development, rapid urbanization and continuous economic growth are accompanied by a steady increase of water consumption and a severe urban water crisis. A better understanding of the relationship among urbanization, economic growth and water use change is necessary for Chinese decision makers at various levels to address the positive and negative effects of urbanization. Thus, we established a complete decomposition model to quantify the driving effects of urbanization on economic growth and water use change for China and its 31 provincial administrative regions during the period of 1997-2011. The results show that, (1) China’s urbanization only contributed about 30% of the economic growth. Therefore, such idea as urbanization is the major driving force of economic growth may be weakened. (2) China’s urbanization increased 2352×10⁸ m³ of water use by increasing the economic aggregate. However, it decreased 4530×10⁸ m³ of water use by optimizing the industrial structure and improving the water use efficiency. Therefore, such idea as urbanization is the major driving force of water demand growth may be reacquainted. (3) Urbanization usually made greater contribution to economic and water use growth in the provincial administrative regions in east and central China, which had larger population and economic aggregate and stepped into the accelerating period of urbanization. However, it also made greater contribution to industrial structure optimization and water use efficiency improvement, and then largely decreased total water use. In total, urbanization had negative effects on water use growth in most provincial administrative regions in China, and the spatiotemporal differences among them were lessened on the whole. (4) Though urbanization helps to decrease water use for China and most provincial administrative regions, it may cause water crisis in urban built-up areas or urban agglomerations. Therefore, China should construct the water transfer and compensation mechanisms between urban and rural areas, or low and high density urban areas as soon as possible.

Key words: urbanization, economic growth, water demand, complete decomposition model, spatiotemporal difference, water resources compensation

Chao BAO, Xiaojie CHEN. The driving effects of urbanization on economic growth and water use change in China: A provincial-level analysis in 1997-2011[J].Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2015, 25(5): 530-544.

Figures/Tables 6

Table 1

Figure 1

Table 2

Comprehensive contribution rates of population urbanization to economic growth by province in China from 1997 to 2011 (%)"

Year	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	1997-2011
China	30.0	27.0	44.6	30.4	33.0	31.2	32.6	31.1	35.4	24.0	33.0	33.7	29.8	32.4	31.6
Beijing	2.9	13.8	-19.7	-14.3	9.6	10.0	7.9	12.1	18.8	6.4	9.6	8.3	8.0	9.6	7.5
Tianjin	4.7	9.5	4.1	2.6	3.1	2.7	2.5	2.7	-0.9	2.2	2.1	2.1	2.0	2.1	2.3
Hebei	28.1	24.8	48.1	32.7	43.5	42.9	40.7	37.6	17.2	32.7	39.6	39.6	33.3	35.3	35.1
Shanxi	21.3	31.9	51.3	21.8	29.0	24.1	26.6	30.1	24.0	19.7	33.6	47.8	21.4	22.4	26.1
Inner Mongolia	29.3	17.5	32.0	22.4	12.0	12.1	10.7	9.9	10.0	11.9	12.8	13.5	15.1	15.6	13.7
Liaoning	10.5	-6.8	2.4	3.7	13.0	11.7	14.4	16.0	14.0	8.2	9.1	9.2	8.6	9.7	9.8
Jilin	1.9	-13.6	-10.5	-4.3	18.6	13.4	14.7	15.5	12.4	6.3	6.6	7.7	7.8	7.8	7.8
Heilongjiang	3.0	12.9	24.2	8.1	18.7	14.6	14.3	13.5	10.5	10.3	10.5	10.7	9.7	9.9	11.5
Shanghai	6.6	-21.3	4.1	29.1	7.7	0.1	0.0	0.1	26.8	4.7	6.2	6.4	4.6	5.0	6.3
Jiangsu	34.2	62.4	73.3	67.7	26.2	28.5	25.2	27.2	19.8	33.4	36.7	36.0	33.8	36.4	34.8
Zhejiang	47.7	48.0	53.7	19.1	24.4	23.5	21.6	29.7	15.0	21.6	29.1	31.4	23.7	29.2	27.0
Anhui	29.3	35.1	37.9	12.4	59.7	54.8	52.3	14.5	36.5	28.8	31.7	31.1	27.9	29.8	32.6
Fujian	33.7	36.7	29.1	27.3	24.8	24.4	22.9	25.5	45.1	24.1	27.0	27.7	24.4	26.4	27.9
Jiangxi	17.4	14.8	53.3	44.0	36.1	36.0	33.5	36.4	4.9	5.8	5.9	3.3	19.6	21.8	19.4
Shandong	9.5	22.2	18.0	16.8	19.2	24.3	28.9	30.6	27.3	25.8	29.3	28.4	27.6	30.0	26.5
Henan	27.0	12.6	22.5	19.7	35.5	32.6	27.9	27.1	30.2	25.2	29.7	32.5	28.9	30.2	28.5
Hubei	30.7	28.6	28.0	38.7	35.2	44.4	35.0	33.8	28.3	26.2	27.6	26.8	24.2	25.1	28.7
Hunan	36.5	33.3	38.2	20.2	55.6	44.9	46.8	44.7	7.1	27.4	29.3	29.6	28.0	31.2	31.4
Guangdong	29.6	26.1	11.9	10.4	19.2	15.1	16.5	16.6	19.9	23.2	29.4	28.9	21.6	24.1	21.6
Guangxi	30.7	26.8	19.5	38.3	28.6	27.0	20.9	43.7	42.9	46.7	36.5	34.0	31.3	35.0	35.0
Hainan	44.0	23.1	23.7	27.0	15.8	13.1	10.0	8.3	45.4	13.6	19.4	16.4	12.5	16.2	18.5
Chongqing	32.5	26.4	67.6	53.2	32.8	31.4	31.1	28.8	56.4	30.0	31.8	30.5	26.7	27.2	32.7
Sichuan	19.7	32.6	35.1	25.9	35.8	39.6	34.6	42.8	35.5	27.9	35.3	28.0	27.0	27.1	31.1
Guizhou	2.7	5.0	14.4	14.5	19.4	25.2	19.2	24.2	-2.5	12.1	15.7	15.7	14.3	12.6	13.8
Yunnan	37.6	49.9	67.8	37.3	38.9	35.3	40.4	38.1	25.4	29.7	33.4	29.8	29.5	27.0	33.2
Tibet	61.2	66.9	68.1	73.5	54.2	48.2	38.3	32.5	29.3	28.0	22.0	45.0	45.3	44.0	42.5
Shaanxi	39.1	29.5	55.4	30.6	33.6	34.3	20.7	25.9	10.9	20.2	19.6	23.0	21.6	22.4	23.6
Gansu	19.8	17.2	38.3	26.9	28.2	46.3	27.0	27.2	37.3	19.5	27.6	27.1	24.1	22.9	27.2
Qinghai	19.0	-9.6	-17.9	55.7	21.7	17.9	13.6	22.7	36.9	17.8	17.8	23.0	15.8	17.7	19.7
Ningxia	18.4	8.5	-13.9	2.1	35.1	32.3	33.7	32.8	14.7	18.5	18.6	19.5	17.4	19.1	19.5
Xinjiang	-9.9	6.0	-12.3	-9.8	19.6	19.4	25.5	19.1	19.2	18.7	20.6	26.8	21.2	19.0	17.2

Table 2

Table 3

Figure 2

Table 4

Comprehensive contributions of population-economic urbanization on water use change by province in China from 1997 to 2011 (108 m3)"

Year	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	1997-2011
China	-141	-117	-147	-156	-195	-267	-27	-143	-150	-359	-72	-112	-176	-115	-2177
Beijing	-2.2	-1.6	-3.5	-3.0	-2.3	-2.4	-2.8	-2.2	-1.9	-2.3	-1.5	-1.0	-2.2	-1.1	-29.9
Tianjin	-0.5	-2.8	-1.5	-1.1	-0.9	-1.4	-1.4	-1.7	-2.3	-2.4	-2.7	-2.2	-2.6	-2.0	-25.5
Hebei	-5.3	-8.2	-3.0	-3.3	-2.4	-4.5	-4.9	-5.4	-13.0	-11.4	-5.2	-6.8	-10.3	-7.3	-91.0
Shanxi	2.1	3.3	8.7	-2.1	3.2	-2.2	-2.9	-5.0	-1.5	-5.9	-1.9	0.6	1.6	-8.1	-10.0
Inner Mongolia	2.7	6.3	-5.0	-8.7	-12.6	-20.9	-12.5	-24.1	-20.3	-22.1	-16.5	-18.0	-13.6	-11.8	-177.3
Liaoning	9.9	-5.3	-13.7	-3.1	-1.0	-4.1	-4.3	-3.9	-6.1	-12.3	-8.3	-11.4	-9.7	-6.6	-79.9
Jilin	6.7	-7.4	29.7	-6.7	-1.2	-3.9	-2.8	-0.6	-6.8	-12.4	-5.4	-5.4	-5.9	-6.6	-28.5
Heilongjiang	4.7	-12.4	-21.2	-2.0	-1.9	-16.8	5.6	-4.4	-6.4	-18.5	-8.8	-11.4	-17.2	-11.5	-122.3
Shanghai	-2.2	-5.1	-1.6	1.3	-0.9	-2.2	-4.4	-5.9	0.0	-3.1	-1.9	-1.8	-4.3	-2.2	-34.2
Jiangsu	-24.8	7.6	8.3	9.1	-17.5	-39.0	-37.3	-26.3	-21.6	-20.4	-12.1	-12.4	-13.6	-11.4	-211.2
Zhejiang	-3.8	-2.9	-1.3	-6.3	-8.0	-13.2	-11.3	-9.9	-12.7	-12.2	-4.7	-5.7	-7.7	-3.8	-103.7
Anhui	-8.1	4.8	-8.9	-51.0	2.1	-9.8	3.4	-12.3	-9.2	-11.2	-18.7	2.9	-13.0	-12.3	-141.3
Fujian	-11.5	-1.0	-7.0	-5.0	-6.0	-8.2	-6.6	-6.0	-5.6	-8.0	-5.8	-5.0	-9.1	-5.0	-89.9
Jiangxi	-20.2	-0.4	5.8	-3.0	-6.2	-11.4	-5.8	-2.8	-1-.6	-112.2	-16.5	-17.1	-15.8	16.2	-199.9
Shandong	-11.6	-9.6	-14.8	-9.9	-17.3	-16.2	-11.1	-14.1	-7.0	-17.4	-9.4	-11.3	-12.0	-9.3	-171.0
Henan	0.0	-0.1	-8.1	-9.4	-5.7	-21.4	5.1	-5.4	-66.2	-14.8	-1.3	-4.8	-9.5	-8.1	-149.6
Hubei	-16.3	-17.0	-7.4	-4.5	-10.4	2.2	-0.7	-4.3	-7.1	-10.3	-4.7	-7.2	-11.1	-9.2	-107.9
Hunan	-14.6	-6.6	-6.9	-11.1	-9.1	-4.1	2.3	-2.5	-20.7	-18.7	-12.6	-12.8	-15.5	-11.4	-144.3
Guangdong	-11.4	-10.1	-29.7	-18.2	-18.3	-32.3	-25.4	-24.2	-24.5	-25.0	-11.2	-6.1	-16.5	-11.3	-264.0
Guangxi	-3.8	3.1	1.5	-6.9	-2.6	-14.0	-9.8	1.7	-6.0	-9.6	-9.6	-12.6	-14.6	-9.6	-92.8
Hainan	1.5	2.4	1.8	1.5	0.5	-0.2	-0.9	-2.2	0.6	-2.9	-0.5	-1.6	-3.6	-2.0	-5.6
Chongqing	-0.3	-0.8	1.1	0.6	0.0	-0.1	0.3	0.1	0.0	1.5	1.3	0.8	0.3	-0.4	4.6
Sichuan	-6.0	-0.8	-4.2	-8.1	-3.4	-2.5	-3.6	-2.1	-8.4	-10.9	-6.7	-4.9	-10.0	-11.0	-82.7
Guizhou	-3.4	-2.9	-3.0	-3.1	-2.9	-1.6	-2.6	-2.5	-6.1	-6.8	-1.8	-3.9	-4.4	-9.1	-54.0
Yunnan	5.5	0.4	4.0	-1.5	-2.5	-1.6	-3.2	-0.3	-4.2	-4.7	-0.3	-5.7	-7.6	-5.8	-27.6
Tibet	-0.9	-0.4	1.3	-0.4	2.5	-2.1	-8.3	-3.9	-1.1	-1.7	-1.2	-2.8	-15.1	-2.5	-36.5
Shaanxi	1.5	-3.4	-0.3	-3.3	-2.2	-2.3	-0.7	-1.9	-3.4	-6.6	-4.3	-5.1	-5.2	-3.7	-40.8
Gansu	-3.3	-7.5	-4.4	-0.2	-0.1	-1.6	-1.1	-3.0	-11.7	-7.4	-1.4	-4.5	-5.3	-5.7	-57.2
Qinghai	-1.2	-1.6	-2.3	-0.3	-1.7	-0.8	-1.7	-1.3	-0.8	-2.2	-0.6	-1.3	-1.5	-1.9	-19.2
Ningxia	3.7	-4.8	-15.4	-4.7	-2.2	-8.1	-12.2	-1.1	-5.3	-5.1	-3.0	-3.3	-4.1	-4.2	-69.9
Xinjiang	-3.7	-56.9	-29.0	-32.7	-15.9	-9.5	-24.7	-19.8	-24.2	-23.4	-20.0	-14.2	-31.0	-26.4	-331.4

Table 4

References 24

1	Ang B W, Zhang F Q, 2000. A survey of index decomposition analysis in energy and environmental studies.Energy, 25(12): 1149-1176.
2	Bao C, 2012. Driving effects of water use change in oasis cities based on the urbanization perspective.Arid Land Geography, 35(6): 988-995. (in Chinese)
3	Bao C, Fang C L, 2006. Study on the quantitative relationship between urbanization and water resources utilization in the Hexi Corridor.Journal of Natural Resources, 21(2): 301-310. (in Chinese)
4	Bao C, Fang C L, 2007. Water resources constraint force on urbanization in water deficient regions: A case study of the Hexi Corridor, arid area of NW China.Ecological Economics, 62(3/4): 508-517.
5	Bao C, Fang C L, 2009. Integrated assessment model of water resources constraint intensity on urbanization and its application in arid area.Journal of Geographical Sciences, 19(2): 273-286.
6	Bao C, Fang C L, 2010. Interaction mechanism and control modes on urbanization and water resources exploitation and utilization.Urban Studies, 17(12): 19-23. (in Chinese)
7	Bao C, Fang C L, 2012. Water resources flows related to urbanization in China: Challenges and perspectives for water management and urban development.Water Resources Management, 26(2): 531-552.
8	Bertinelli L, Black D, 2004. Urbanization and growth.Journal of Urban Economics, 56(1): 80-96.
9	Brown L R, 2001. How water scarcity will shape the new century.Water Science and Technology, 43(4): 17-22.
10	Chen A P, Partridge M D, 2013. When are cities engines of growth in China? Spread and backwash effects across the urban hierarchy.Regional Studies, 47(8): 1313-1331.
11	Fang C Let al., 2009. Report on China’s Urbanization and the Guarantee of Resources and Eco-environment. Beijing: Science Press. (in Chinese)
12	Jenerette G D, Larsen L, 2006. A global perspective on changing sustainable urban water supplies.Global and Planetary Change, 50(3/4): 202-211.
13	Jia S F, Zhang S F, Yang Het al., 2004. Relation of industrial water use and economic development: Water use Kuznets Curve. Journal of Natural Resources, 19(3): 279-284. (in Chinese)
14	Lin X Q, Wang D, Ren W Bet al., 2013. Research on the mechanism of urbanization to economic increase in China.Geographical Research, 32(4): 691-700. (in Chinese)
15	Liu J X, Wang Q, Sun Pet al., 2008. Decomposition effect on China’s annual ecological footprints variation from 1990 to 2004.Journal of Natural Resources, 23(1): 61-68. (in Chinese)
16	Liu Y B, Li R D, Song X F, 2005. Grey associative analysis of regional urbanization and eco-environment coupling in China.Acta Geographica Sinica, 60(2): 237-247. (in Chinese)
17	Merrett S, 1997. Introduction to the Economics of Water Resources: An International Perspective. UCL Press.
18	Shen J F, 2006. Estimating urbanization levels in Chinese provinces in 1982-2000.International Statistical Review, 74(1): 89-107.
19	Song J J, Zhang Q J, Liu Y Q, 2004. Analysis and suggestions on water resources security in 2020 in China.China Water Resources, (9): 14-17. (in Chinese)
20	Sun C Z, Wang Y, 2010. Decomposition of driving effects for industrial water utilization change and spatial temporal difference in Liaoning Province.Geographical Research, 29(2): 244-252. (in Chinese)
21	Sun J W, 1998. Changes in energy consumption and energy intensity: A complete decomposition model.Energy Economics, 20(1): 85-100.
22	Zhang Q, Wang B D, Cao M L, 2011. Analysis of water resource utilization change based on factor decomposition model.Journal of Natural Resources, 26(7): 1209-1216. (in Chinese)
23	Zhou Y X, 1995. Urban Geography. Shanghai: The Commercial Press. (in Chinese)
24	Zhou Y X, Yu H B, 2002. Suggestions on reconstructing the urbanization levels in China based on the fifth population census.Statistical Research, (4): 44-47. (in Chinese)

Year	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	1997-2011
ΔE	586	614	732	781	925	1114	1233	1523	1900	2391	1857	1947	2411	2369	20385
P_eff	68	90	137	75	65	68	98	92	126	120	128	134	141	149	1491
I_eff	421	434	400	576	692	855	912	1170	1398	1963	1389	1448	1876	1797	15330
S_eff	97	91	195	131	169	191	223	261	376	308	340	365	394	424	3564
SI_eff	79	75	131	107	136	156	179	213	296	266	273	291	325	343	2872
U_eff	176	166	326	238	305	348	402	474	672	574	613	656	719	768	6436
ΔI	421	422	473	555	672	812	875	1095	1347	1713	1296	1350	1680	1635	14346
II_eff	342	349	318	452	540	663	703	896	1062	1481	1041	1078	1389	1322	11637
IS_eff	79	73	155	103	132	148	172	200	285	232	255	272	291	312	2709

Year	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006	2007	2008	2009	2010	2011	1997-2011
ΔW	-131	155	-93	70	-70	-256	225	75	162	11	77	72	40	93	429
EP_eff	415	405	449	441	482	514	515	590	672	758	530	514	585	529	7399
EI_eff	-391	-77	-325	-174	-330	-514	-166	-312	-251	-392	-306	-263	-326	-255	-4081
ES_eff	-155	-173	-217	-198	-221	-256	-124	-204	-260	-355	-147	-179	-219	-181	-2888
ESI_eff	-111	-53	-130	-93	-133	-171	-71	-123	-127	-186	-99	-106	-131	-106	-1641
EU_eff	-266	-226	-348	-290	-354	-427	-195	-327	-387	-541	-246	-285	-350	-287	-4530
QEP_eff	125	109	200	134	159	160	168	184	238	182	175	173	175	171	2352
ΔWU	-141	-117	-147	-156	-195	-267	-27	-143	-150	-359	-72	-112	-176	-115	-2177
ΔEI	-70.3	-29.8	-60.0	-37.9	-51.8	-66.0	-22.6	-36.3	-32.0	-41.3	-22.4	-20.0	-22.5	-16.4	-529.2
EII_eff	-50.3	-9.2	-36.0	-17.7	-31.0	-44.1	-12.9	-21.9	-15.7	-21.7	-15.1	-11.9	-13.4	-9.6	-310.6
EIS_eff	-20.0	-20.6	-24.0	-20.2	-20.8	-22.0	-9.7	-14.3	-16.3	-19.6	-7.3	-8.1	-9.0	-6.8	-218.7

[1]	FENG Yuxue, LI Guangdong. Interaction between urbanization and eco-environment in the Tibetan Plateau [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2021, 31(2): 298-324.
[2]	FANG Chuanglin, CUI Xuegang, DENG Xiangzheng, LIANG Longwu. Urbanization and eco-environment coupling circle theory and coupler regulation [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(7): 1043-1059.
[3]	SONG Zhouying, ZHU Qiaoling. Spatio-temporal pattern and driving forces of urbanization in China’s border areas [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(5): 775-793.
[4]	SONG Xiaoqing, WEN Mengmeng, SHEN Yajing, FENG Qi, XIANG Jingwei, ZHANG Weina, ZHAO Guosong, WU Zhifeng. Urban vacant land in growing urbanization: An international review [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(4): 669-687.
[5]	LIU Haimeng, FANG Chuanglin, FANG Kai. Coupled Human and Natural Cube: A novel framework for analyzing the multiple interactions between humans and nature [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(3): 355-377.
[6]	CUI Xuegang, FANG Chuanglin, LIU Haimeng, LIU Xiaofei, LI Yonghong. Dynamic simulation of urbanization and eco-environment coupling: Current knowledge and future prospects [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(2): 333-352.
[7]	ZHANG Xinhuan, XU Wenqiang, XIANG Xinyi, ZHANG Zhiping, CUI Mingjie. Mechanism of interaction between urbanization and resource environment in Central Asia [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(11): 1723-1738.
[8]	MA Haitao, SUN Zhan. Comprehensive urbanization level and its dynamic factors for five Central Asian countries [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(11): 1761-1780.
[9]	HUANG Jinchuan, NA Ying, GUO Yu. Spatiotemporal characteristics and driving mechanism of the coupling coordination degree of urbanization and ecological environment in Kazakhstan [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(11): 1802-1824.
[10]	ZHOU Yannan, YANG Yu, SONG Zhouying, HE Ze, XIA Siyou, REN Yawen. Dynamic transition mechanism analysis of the impact of energy development on urbanization in Central Asia [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(11): 1825-1848.
[11]	JING Cheng, TAO Hui, JIANG Tong, WANG Yanjun, ZHAI Jianqing, CAO Lige, SU Buda. Population, urbanization and economic scenarios over the Belt and Road region under the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2020, 30(1): 68-84.
[12]	LYU Lachang, SUN Feixiang, HUANG Ru. Innovation-based urbanization: Evidence from 270 cities at the prefecture level or above in China [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2019, 29(8): 1283-1299.
[13]	Liying GUO, Liping DI, Qing TIAN. Detecting spatio-temporal changes of arable land and construction land in the Beijing-Tianjin corridor during 2000-2015 [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2019, 29(5): 702-718.
[14]	ZHUANG Liang, YE Chao, HU Senlin. Spatial production and spatial dialectic: Evidence from the New Urban Districts in China [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2019, 29(12): 1981-1998.
[15]	CHEN Mingxing, YE Chao, LU Dadao, SUI Yuwen, GUO Shasha. Cognition and construction of the theoretical connotations of new urbanization with Chinese characteristics [J]. Journal of Geographical Sciences, 2019, 29(10): 1681-1698.